Why we need a law on HATE CRIME | Pocketmags.com

2 mins

Why we need a law on HATE CRIME

On March 10 this year, the Seanad approved a motion for Ireland to opt in to new EU measures to combat and prohibit hate speech. Consequently, it called on the government to start working on implementing effective legislation against hate crimes. This represents a big step forward, explains Beatrice Fanucci considering that minority groups in the country, LGBTQ+ people included, still have no appropriate protection against hate violence.

I am from Italy and last year members of the Senate cheered loudly and applauded as if they were in a stadium when a law that would protect queer people from discrimination and violence was tanked. The rage that learning about it caused is something I can still experience while writing this piece. The LGBTQ+ community in Italy have been waiting for such legislation for decades. The first attempt at introducing it was made in 2002 and now, 20 years later, my country still has no law that recognises a discriminatory motive for hate crimes perpetrated against queer folks.

I believe that the lack of such legislation is simply not acceptable anymore, in either of our countries. Because refusing to recognise a hate motive for these crimes is disregarding completely their core element, the very reason why they happen in the first place.

According to the Organisation for Security and Cooperation in Europe (OSCE), there are two elements that make a hate crime: an act that constitutes criminal offence and a bias motive. This second element is what distinguishes a hate crime from any other crime, because it means that the perpetrator chooses the survivor based on the prejudice they have against them. I use the term ‘survivor’ instead of ‘victim’ because the latter has negative connotations associated with weakness, helplessness and passivity and thus fails to grasp the resilience and the active role of a person who has suffered violence in overcoming the consequences of the aggression.

Portrait by Stefano Pappalardo.

The survivor is thus chosen because the perpetrator perceives them as belonging to a certain social group. Hate crimes are usually directed against members of groups who are already marginalised in society, and they are used as a mechanism of oppression. They are the consequence of a political culture that grants rights and privileges on the basis of people’s social characteristics. As such, hate crimes are an extension of the racism, sexism, ableism, homophobia and transphobia that are already present in our society. This is the very reason why they cannot and should not be considered as isolated incidents to be dealt with separately. This is why we need a system to recognise them and to combat them as a whole phenomenon. This is why we need appropriate legislation.

Not having such laws means that survivors of hate crimes will not be able to access justice or the appropriate support they need after their experiences. It has been demonstrated that the lack of legislation leads survivors to perceive reporting the crime to the police as inconsequential. Moreover, studies have found that crimes with a hate motive are more debilitating than other crimes and often impair survivors from taking further action.

The lack of a law also means not being able to monitor the scope of the phenomenon, as no comprehensive data on hate crimes are currently available, since most of them are not recognised as such. And finally, it means not having an effective strategy to combat a problem that goes beyond a single survivor and attacker. The entire community the survivor belongs to is impacted by the violence and the message that lies behind it. The dynamics of a hate crime involve the creation of sentiments of fear and suspicion in the targeted community.

By adopting proper legislation, the State would send a message that such aggressions will not be tolerated, that perpetrators will be punished and that LGBTQ+ people will be protected.

And that is the kind of message we need.

This article appears in 371

Go to Page View
This article appears in...
Go to Page View
Keep up to date across our socials: @gaycommunitynews
Community NXF – New Team - 2022
In memory of maken
Community In Memory – maken – Tribute
Why we need a law on HATE CRIME
Community Hate Crime – Laws – Protection
Community Spirasi – Befriending – Volunteers
Community Growing - Coming Out - Self-acceptance
Feature Flikkers -Bealtaine -Exhibition
Interview Music - Creativity - Art
Feature Front Lounge -Memory Lane -Queer History
Interview Pillow Queens - Leave The Light On - Music
The World Needs A STAGE
Culture Theatre – Writing – Art
United Against War
On February 24, 2022, Russian forces invaded Ukraine, leading to continued bombardment, thousands of deaths, and, at the time of writing, the displacement of around one quarter of the entire population. In response to the ongoing situation, Oisín Kenny lists various organisations appealing for donations to fund the urgent supplies of shelter, food, medication and psychological support needed, and to assist relocation to safe places
Dating and Difference MONEY
Discrimination is often directed towards certain lifelong experiences. This makes it easier for people to judge, fuelled by some sort of “I’m not like them and I’ll never be like them” notion. It’s much easier to throw dodgy comments or think problematic thoughts towards someone if it’s not possible for you to fully relate to them, describes Adrian Colwell.
Interview Music - Creativity - Art
Liam Geraghty and Peter Dunne, creators of the award-winning horror anthology podcast Petrified.
Looking for back issues?
Browse the Archive >

Previous Article Next Article
Page 8