A State of Silence | Pocketmags.com

10 mins

A State of Silence

21 years later, Direct Provision remains Ireland’s only process for the accommodation of asylum applicants, most of whom spend several months, if not years in the system. With promised changes on the way, Aoife Burke looks at the system’s inherent failings and holds those promises up to the light.

Photos by Hazel Coonagh.

Direct Provision began in Ireland in 2000 as a temporary, emergency measure for accommodating asylum applicants. Even at the time of its implementation, the system was not designed to appropriately and permanently meet Ireland’s obligations under international human rights law, nor was it intended to accommodate people seeking asylum for extended periods.

The human rights violations perpetrated by Direct Provision are well documented, with many residents living without access to basic privacy, dignity and freedoms.

This year, after two decades of organised resistance by asylum seekers and allies, the government released a White Paper outlining a plan to replace Direct Provision with a more human rights compliant approach. The White Paper is a pivotal moment for asylum policy in Ireland, however reactions to its publication have been mixed. Many have praised what is being seen as an end to Direct Provision, with others arguing the new system retains many of the same problems as the old. It remains to be seen whether the government’s plans will be implemented on schedule, whether the changes will be sufficient to protect current and future applicants and whether the Irish state will ever compensate for the injustices that have dominated our asylum system for so long.

Though there may now be an opportunity for positive change going forward, the scars left by the last 21 years of Ireland’s asylum policy cannot be forgotten. Because the system is privatised, conditions in Direct Provision centres vary quite drastically, however major failings in the accommodation system have been exposed in several centres throughout the country. Poverty, institutionalisation, a lack of privacy, inadequate food, overcrowded, unclean conditions and abuse and mistreatment from management are among the many issues that have been highlighted through the testimony of asylum seekers.

At times, the extent of these violations has led residents to take extreme measures in the fight for their rights. Just last year, several residents at the since-closed Skellig Star Direct Provision Centre in Kerry went on hunger strike, demanding to be moved to a centre with adequate facilities. There have already been at least two other hunger strikes by asylum seekers since then, one by a single resident in the Mosney Direct Provision Centre and another by an estimated 90 residents at Ashbourne House centre in Cork.

These strikes are a harrowing reminder of the suffering that has so often been swept under the rug in Irish society. They force us to consider not only how things can be improved in the future, but also how we can ever amend for the past. The Movement for Asylum Seekers in Ireland (MASI) have commented that while the government’s “route of travel is to end Direct Provision, there seems to be no appreciation of the harm caused by Direct Provision on the 60,000 plus people who have gone through it over the years, hence the need for a tribunal to investigate breaches of fundamental human rights in Direct Provision for appropriate redress.”

In looking back at the failings of Direct Provision since 2000, it is important to recognise that the system has often placed a disproportionate burden on minority groups, including the LGBTQ+ community. I spoke to Preet, a refugee who has been in Direct Provision for three years and who explained to us how queer asylum seekers are at particular risk. Preet’s country of origin is Mauritius where, she explained, LGBTQ+ people are not accepted at all and are often seen as being possessed. Having endured intense social pressure, homophobic abuse and death threats in Mauritius, Preet fled to Ireland for safety. However, she soon found herself enduring similar homophobic abuse in Direct Provision.

After staying in the reception centre in Balseskin, Preet was moved to the Hazel Hotel centre in Kildare, where she shared a communal room and bathroom with eight other people, all of whom were homophobic. Preet explained how homophobic abuse compounded the existing pressure of the asylum process; “You’re already so, so stressed about IPO [International Protection Office], if you’re going to get a positive result or not, what’s in store for you, and now this”.

She reached out to the International Protection Accommodation Service (IPAS) several times, explaining her situation and requesting to be moved to another centre, but her pleas fell on deaf ears. She explained, “IPAS really need to sympathise with LGBT people because when we are requesting them to give us an LGBT roommate, to be honest, they don’t care”. Preet also highlighted how the isolated rural settings of many Direct Provision centres mean that LGBTQ+ asylum seekers do not have access to necessary support services; “I’m currently in Athlone, there’s no LGBT counselling, there’s nothing for LGBT people, there’s no LGBT network compared to Dublin”.

As well as inequalities in accommodation, queer asylum seekers are also disproportionately harmed by failings in the assessment process. The Irish Refugee Council have highlighted that there is a “culture of disbelief” among refugee status decision-makers in Ireland who have demonstrated a repeated failure to acknowledge the applicant’s testimony as evidence in and of itself.

LGBTQ+ people are at particular risk of falling victim to this culture of disbelief as there is often no evidence of a person’s sexuality or gender identity beyond their word. Early this year, it was exposed that in the asylum case of a bisexual Nigerian man, it was asserted that “it is simply not credible that a young man having being raised in …a restrictive environment would engage in behaviour both unacceptable and outlawed in the society in which he lives.” This conclusion disregarded not only the lived experience of the applicant himself, but also perpetuated the erasure of Ireland’s own queer history, for years of which LGBTQ+ experiences existed outside of the law.

Given the particular damage caused to LGBTQ+ people by Ireland’s international protection process, it is no surprise that the fight for the rights of asylum-seekers has often held an important space in queer movements. Preet noted the strong bonds between these two intersecting communities, describing how queer organisations “fight for LGBT asylum seekers and the LGBT Irish community… they are always here for everyone”. She explained how her involvement in Outhouse and LGBT Ireland have been a source of comfort and empowerment throughout her journey, particularly in peer support groups for queer asylum seekers. She said that even if it is just once a month, these meetings make her life easier and boost her morale.

This empowerment is ultimately a two-way street. The involvement and contribution of queer asylum seekers, many of whom have overcome extreme forms of bigotry, is invaluable to the struggle for LGBTQ+ rights. Preet explained that because of her openness and selfexpression she is often called on to be a spokesperson within queer organisations and described it as a “privilege” to be able to make this contribution. As Ireland moves towards a new international protection model, this kind of mutual solidarity between queer and asylum seeker movements is arguably more important than ever before.

An essential step in building solidarity is understanding Ireland’s asylum policy, how it is progressing and how the LGBTQ+ community can help shape it. The White Paper to End Direct Provision was published in February this year by the Department of Children and Equality and outlines plans to move from Direct Provision to a new international protection support service by the end of 2024. Under the new system, congregated accommodation would still be used for single people, however, all centres would be stateowned and all applicants would be entitled to own-door accommodation after four months. The new system would also be time-bound, with all applicants receiving their final decision within 12 months.

If implemented, these changes could end the legal limbo many asylum seekers find themselves in for years and raise the standard of accommodation in line with the basic human rights of applicants. However, there are no plans to put maximum stays in reception centres or limits on processing times on a statutory footing, meaning that asylum seekers may still face lengthy stays in congregated settings. Because there would be no means to legally hold the government to account in such cases, some have been sceptical of whether the model set out in the White Paper would truly represent an end to Direct Provision.

Furthermore, many have highlighted that four years is too long a wait to end a system in which extensive human rights abuses have already been acknowledged.

In its favour, the White Paper does recognise the specific risks facing marginalised groups in the international protection system, including LGBTQ+ people. It is planned that the new model will use vulnerability assessments to take account of the needs of queer applicants, particularly transgender people and LGBTQ+ youth. Caseworkers are to be appropriately trained to recognise the risks of homophobia and transphobia in reception centres and the accessibility of LGBTQ+ support services will be considered in sourcing own-door accommodation for queer applicants. However, as is the case with several issues raised in the White Paper, the specific policies for accommodating LGBTQ+ asylum seekers have yet to be fleshed out. It is stated that engagement with LGBTQ+ NGO’s will inform the development of policy, however ensuring that queer rights are on the agenda over the next four years of implementation will likely require pressure from the community.

Ultimately, while the guiding principles and some specific details of the new system have been laid out in the White Paper, the coming months and years will determine exactly how this outline is interpreted and implemented. The voice of asylum seekers, particularly those of marginalised identities, must be front and centre in the development of the new system. However, this is not guaranteed. The implementation of the new model will be overseen by a programme board chaired by the Department of Children and Equality which will include “at least one person who has transited through the Direct Provision system”. Due to a lack of standardisation, the experience of Direct Provision is extremely diverse and is greatly impacted by factors such as gender, sexuality, age, disability and race. For this reason, many have argued that one individual cannot possibly represent the lived reality of Direct Provision or the many different groups who go through the system.

Speaking on the progression of the White Paper, Preet emphasised that meaningful participation of those in Direct Provision is essential and that the government must now “ask the asylum seekers, speak to the asylum seekers and hear what we have to suggest.” Preet argues that while Direct Provision may be ending, LGBTQ+ protection applicants cannot wait four years for their voices to be heard and their needs to be met. She believes that in the interim, the government should provide specific accommodation for LGBTQ+ people and that this should be located in Dublin where there is access to necessary services and support networks; “I’m not saying that if only LGBT people live together life will be a bed of roses, but if there was an LGBT Centre, at least you could breathe .There would be freedom and you wouldn’t have to be scared of other people.”

Queer asylum seekers are, like everyone else, a diverse group with a wide range of perspectives. Some have argued that rather than fighting for an LGBT centre, the focus should remain on the abolition of Direct Provision altogether. The lack of consensus seen on some of these issues further highlights how having just one individual represent the voice of asylum seekers is not sufficient. If we really are to see liberation for international protection applicants in Ireland, it will be through raising a collective voice, and all the nuance and compromise that entails.

Ultimately, asylum seekers have always made themselves heard collectively, through actions of solidarity and through pressure on governments that have otherwise looked the other way. When asked what we can do to fight for the rights of asylum seekers going forward, Preet answered “it’s already happening”. She explained that LGBTQ+ activists have been fighting for asylum seekers for 20 years and that this is just one small sub-group of a much bigger movement. She highlighted how throughout the history of Direct Provision, groups have communicated and come together in this broader struggle, taking needed actions from simply signing petitions to protesting deportations.

The movement “is already existing and it’s going to be here until Direct Provision is abolished”.

This article appears in 367

Go to Page View
This article appears in...
Go to Page View
From The Team
Stefano, Dave, Katie, Marlon, Peter and Lisa.
The National LGBT Federation (NXF) partnered with Dublin Pride
Coming Out with Pride
With no colourful Pride Parade making its way through the centre of Dublin, members of the LGBTQ+ community who had wanted to use the moment to ‘come out’ or to celebrate recently doing so, sadly didn’t have the chance
100 K IN MAY
Throughout the month of May GCN partnered with Life Style Sports on the #GCN100KinMay campaign. Ian Smith got the lowdown from some of the awesome Life Style Sports staff who took up the challenge.
National Lottery celebrating LGBTQ+ organisations during Pride
Since 1987, National Lottery players have raised over €6 billion euro for worthy causes, helping people and organisations to further help others. The National Lottery Good Causes Awards celebrates all the incredible work done by individuals and groups across Ireland to give back to their communities and to be there for those in need. Katie Donohoe spoke to three LGBTQ+ organisations that made it all the ways to the finals
The Power of Being Yourself in the Workplace
Roberto Sy from Accenture speaks to Ian Smith about his coming out journey, moving to Ireland and being part of a workplace LGBTQ+ network
Living with Pride
A major photographic exhibition featuring the work of Christopher Robson is launched by the National Library of Ireland.
A face-painted battler unbeaten. A stark, masked figure in an apocalyptic industrial setting. An explosion of colour in an oilstained garage. Veda is all of these things at once in a brave and startling series of images captured by the unstoppable, visionary, Babs Daly. The icon of the Irish drag world chats to Peter Dunne about collaborations, HIV activism and finding freedom in the middle of a pandemic
Rebecca Kelly spoke with Ronan Crinion, the founder and managing director of MoveHome about their recent expansion and what COVID-19 means for the property market
We Need To Talk
“Ableism is still rife within the Irish queer community, and it’s about time we talked about it,” says Alannah Murray
You've heard of LGBTQ+ - Well I am the Plus
It’s hard to come out. The institutionalised shame and guilt we feel around our true identities often stops us from showing them to the world. But coming out becomes harder when you don’t have a word for who you are and how you feel. Louise Blake shares her own journey of discovery
Leveling the Playing Field
As the International Gay Rugby organisation celebrates its 20th anniversary this year with a host of new initiatives and events, Alice Linehan hears about the 134 queer clubs existing worldwide and discovers why so many have found a second home within the inclusive community
For Mother Mary and her Petulant, Devilish Daughters
The history of Ireland, both it’s colonial and postcolonial stories of nationhood, revolved around one’s propensity for incarceration, argues Keeva Boyle-Darby, the ability of those in power, be it British colonial rule or more recently the Catholic Church and their governmental ‘cahooters’ to ostracise the ‘other’
A World to Discover
LGBTQ+ history is as diverse as it is rich, and much of it remains uncovered. Pride Month sees some of those stories brought to light, and, as Brian Dillon discovered, few may be as thought-provoking as that of Irish LGBTQ+ diaspora. Photos by Leon Farrell
The Art of Reflection
Throughout the centuries, artists have responded to their culture, their times, capturing feelings, the mood of the nation. The queer community know only too well the power of slogans and images during the years we couldn’t be out, the years when the odds were stacked against us
Child of Drag
Just in time for Pride, enjoy this jawdropping photo spread featuring a lineup of drag children celebrating the queer community
Teanga Dhúchais
As a queer writer trying to find his voice, Ethan Moser became aware of another barrier facing Irish LGBTQ+ creatives who want to communicate in their native tongue -the lack of representation and opportunity for queer lives lived as Gaeilge
Long Live the Queens
What started (and continued) as a fundraiser for the LGBTQ+ community soon rivalled Pride as the biggest Irish queer event of the year. Hannah Tiernan remembers the iconic, euphoric, Alternative Miss Ireland
Outside the Capitals
After finding himself upon moving away from home, Ross Hunter discovered queer spaces he thought were low on the ground upon returning to small(er) town life
For Our Pleasure
While dancing has been relegated to bedrooms, back gardens and balconies for the last 18 months, it hasn’t dulled Jessie Ware’s desire to get the party started. The artist speaks to Conor Behan about music, life and lockdown
Yes, Sexual Racism is a Thing
“They say, ‘Beauty is in the eye of the beholder’ but having been exposed to the Dublin gay dating scene for over eight years, I could change it to ‘Beauty is in the eye of the people of a majoritarian ethnic group’,”
Health without the care?
With fear of judgement leading to many feeling they can’t be open with healthcare providers, Ian Smith looks at the reality for many older LGBTQ+ people who are accessing services in Ireland today
Sexual (Re)Awakening
During lockdown, there have been massive reckonings, revolutions and reawakenings around sex and sexual health in Ireland. Artists, activists, organisations, students and sex workers speak with Oisin Kenny about adapting to a pandemic and what this means going forward
Full Equality
LGBTQ+ Traveller, author and activist, Oein DeBhairduin, shares with Ed Redmond why Pride needs to remain a protest until all members of the community are valued equally
Sex & Intimacy During Lockdown
Sex is an important, indispensable activity for the realisation and formation of a sexual identity, giving expression to someone’s erotic and emotional feelings and behaviours. David Boyd speaks about how Covid-19 altered many aspects of our lives including our sexual ones
Growing Up Gay in the North
It’s hard to explain what it’s like growing up in Northern Ireland, to someone who never has, describes
A State of Silence
21 years later, Direct Provision remains Ireland’s only process for the accommodation of asylum applicants, most of whom spend several months, if not years in the system. With promised changes on the way, Aoife Burke looks at the system’s inherent failings and holds those promises up to the light
An Irish Solution to an Irish Problem
When the Irish public think about AIDS, much of their understanding of the pandemic comes from British and American media. Angels in America, Dallas Buyers Club and this year’s phenomenal It’s A Sin are all important stories, but they’re not Irish stories. Ezra Moloney looked at the history of AIDS activism, and learned a lot in the process
By Any Other Name
History is more than just a school subject, it’s a remembrance of communities coming together to make their voices heard, and the history of Pride is no different. Catherine E Hug was fortunate to sit down with Kieran Rose, a key political activist for LGBTQ+ rights in Ireland, and hear about his involvement from equality legislation and the establishment of GLEN in the ‘80s, to meeting the President in the ‘90s, to the Marriage Referendum and the celebration of Pride today.
Twin Towns
On the 12th of October 2020, Cork County Council severed the twinning between Fermoy, and the Polish town Nowa Dęba, which had pledged to “defend against aggressive, deceptive and harmful LGBT ideology”. Haritha Olaganathan speaks to activists working to make progressive change on the ground in Poland
Manic Energy
Ella Bowler catches up with alt-pop singer Rebecca Locke and alt-indie band Mothmom to talk about fostering creativity in a city that doesn’t always facilitate the arts
Why Do We Still Need Pride?
Managing Editor Lisa Connell addresses the question that comes up like clockwork every year from those who don’t realise the fight for LGBTQ+ rights is far from over
Looking for back issues?
Browse the Archive >

Previous Article Next Article
Page 114