The Book Guy |

17 mins

The Book Guy

A Keeper

by Graham Norton

(Hodder and Stoughton)

Following the publication of two very successful autobiographies, Graham Norton surprised many in autumn 2016 with the release of his fi rst novel, Holding. Set in a small Irish town that descends into chaos when a long-buried body is unearthed, the story’s brilliant protagonist and the nuanced portrayal of its female characters led the book to be one of the biggest sellers of the year. October now sees the publication of the eagerly anticipated follow-up, A Keeper.

Elizabeth Keane has returned home from New York to Kilkenny in order to tie up some loose ends following the death of her mother. It’s a convenient escape for her; her teenage son, Zach, has been packed off to San Francisco to her feckless and neglectful gay ex-husband, and the sale of her mother’s house will ease the fi nancial pressures on getting her son through college. She begins a tentative romance, while also trying to uncover the truth behind her own father’s identity after discovering a treasure trove of love letters.

Running parallel to Elizabeth’s story is the tale of her mother, Patricia, from 40 years before. When she places a lonely hearts ad in The Irish Farmer’s Journal, Patricia meets Edward Foley, a shy bachelor from rural Cork who lives with his mother. Events take a sinister turn when Patricia fi nds out that her prospective mother-in-law has become more involved in their relationship than she fi rst thought.

Sadly, A Keeper isn’t as accomplished, or subtle, a book as Holding. Whereas Norton’s debut invested time in developing the emotional lives of the characters and building a sense of their community and shared histories, A Keeper lurches from one hysterical plot point to the next with no real sense of who the characters are or why we should have any sympathy for them. There’s a very engaging and heartfelt story at the core of the book, but it gets buried under layers of excessive storyline, when all we really need is a bit more time spent getting to know Elizabeth, Patricia and Edward better.

This new book feels like a race to the nish, or to deadline, with too much needing to be wrapped up by the end. There’s no question that Norton’s a good writer and Holding showed that he’s well able to get to grips with the intricacies of human relationships. And while this book is undoubtedly a disappointment, won’t be giving up on Norton’s writing just yet.

If you like this, you might also like…


by Naomi Alderman


Coming soon to a big screen near you is Sebastián Lelio’s (A Fantastic Woman) adaptation of Naomi Alderman’s 2006 novel Disobedience. Following the death of her father, wisecracking Ronit returns from New York to the orthodox London Jewish suburb to confront the turmoil she left behind following her relationship with another woman, Esti. While Alderman’s novel came in for criticism from the Jewish community on its publication, it is an intriguing look into an orthodox community through the eyes of an unconventional character.

Take Nothing With You

by Patrick Gale

(Tinder Press)

Fiftysomething Eustace finds himself locked in a lead-lined room for thyroid cancer treatment with nothing but cello music for company. The music transports him back to his eccentric 1970’s childhood in Weston-Super-Mare, and the cello lessons he took at his mother’s behest.

Fans of Gale have had a three-year-long wait for this follow-up to A Place Called Winter, and this subtle, moving and hugely enjoyable novel won’t disappoint.

This article appears in 346

Go to Page View
This article appears in...
Go to Page View
Looking for back issues?
Browse the Archive >

Page 18